Nationwide Delivery. Next Day Available

Cookies and Cream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New! Our Cookies and Cream Smith Island Cake is a made from scratch, moist chocolate cake, with Buttercream and Oreo Cookie Frosting. All topped with crushed Oreo Cookies! The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.…

Double Chocolate Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Our Double Chocolate Smith Island Cake is a chocolate lover's dream. Made from scratch, it features layers of moist chocolate cake, and our homemade fudge frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a gorgeous, recyclable box.…

Old Bay Buttercream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New! Our boldest flavor yet! If you love Old Bay (or even if you don't) you will LOVE this cake. Sweet, creamy, a little spicy, a little salty, and unmistakably delicious. Made-from-scratch moist Vanilla Cake, and an Old Bay Buttercream Frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is…

Original Chocolate Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Enjoy the Cake that Launched a Thousand Ships!â„¢ The Original Chocolate Smith Island Cake is by far our most popular offering, and is Maryland's State Dessert. Made from scratch featuring layers of moist yellow cake and a wonderful fudge frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Shipped frozen with dry ice in a…

Strawberry Cream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Considering Marion Station, Maryland, just up the road from Crisfield, is known as "the strawberry capital of the world", it's only fitting SIBC feature a cake worthy of such a legacy! Featuring our moist, made from scratch yellow cake, a decadent strawberry filling, and our fabulous buttercream frosting. This cake is the perfect compliment to any gathering. The cake is…

Strawberry Lemon Coconut Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New! Perfect for spring! Featuring moist vanilla cake, alternating layers of strawberry and lemon curd filling, wrapped in vanilla buttercream, and hand patted with toasted coconut. Always made from scratch, and guaranteed to amaze! The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a…

Vanilla Buttercream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New! Our wildly popular, made-from-scratch moist Vanilla Cake, and our fabulous Buttercream Frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.…

Double Chocolate Raspberry Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Our Double Chocolate and Raspberry Smith Island Cake is made from scratch, and is a wonderful combination of moist chocolate layers, cooked fudge icing, and raspberry. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a gorgeous, recyclable box.…

Cooked Coconut Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

The most wonderful coconut cake in the world, our Cooked Coconut Smith Island Cake just melts in your mouth! It features layers of moist coconut cake, an amazing cooked coconut icing, and is covered in coconut shavings. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry…

Banana Cream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Featuring layers of moist, made from scratch banana cake, and covered in our rich buttercream icing, this is sure to please the most discerning of palates. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.…

Caramel Cream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Our take on the Southern classic is guaranteed to amaze! Featuring layers of moist yellow cake, housemade caramel, and a light, fluffy caramel buttercream. Each cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. The cake is shipped frozen with dry ice in a gorgeous, recyclable box.…

Red Velvet Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

There's red velvet, and then there's Red Velvet! Our Red Velvet Smith Island Cake is in a league of its own. Made from scratch and featuring layers of moist Red Velvet cake and our signature buttercream frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry…

Red White and Blue Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New for the Fourth of July - our Red White and Blue Smith Island Cake! Made from scratch alternating blueberry and red velvet cake with our buttercream frosting. Approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 6-8 slices. Shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.…

Lemon Cream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Originally developed exclusively for Nordstrom Cafe, this cake features moist, made from scratch lemon cake, a wonderful housemade lemon curd between every layer, and lemon buttercream frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a gorgeous, recyclable box.…

Chocolate Buttercream Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New! Made-from-scratch Chocolate Cake, and our fabulous Buttercream Frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.…

Chocolate Peanut Butter Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Our wildly popular, made-from-scratch Chocolate and Peanut Butter Smith Island Cake now available in a smaller size! Featuring layers of moist yellow cake, and alternating layers of fudge frosting and peanut butter, the cake is approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a gorgeous, recyclable…

Apple Cinnamon Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New! A moist, delicious apple and cinnamon cake with our Caramel Buttercream frosting, topped with brown sugar streusel. All made from scratch. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter and 3.5" tall, and yields 6-8 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.…

Carrot Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

Enjoy our take on Carrot! Each cake is made from scratch with real carrots, comprises layers of moist carrot cake and is frosted with a classic buttercream frosting. The cake is approx. 6" in diameter and 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Like all SIBC products, it is shipped frozen with dry ice in a gorgeous, recyclable box.…

Maple Brown Sugar and Bacon Smith Island Cake (Smaller)

New for Father's Day, our Maple, Brown Sugar and Candied Bacon Smith Island Cake! Made from scratch yellow cake, maple syrup and brown sugar buttercream and topped with bacon candied with brown sugar, maple syrup and black pepper. Approx. 6" in diameter, 3.5" tall, and yields 7-9 slices. Shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.…

Result Pages: