Larger Cakes (Serves ~16)
Carrot Walnut Smith Island Cake (Larger)
NEW! The ultimate Carrot Cake, made with Toasted Black Walnuts and Raisins! Each cake is made from scratch with real carrots, comprises layers of moist carrot cake, toasted black walnuts, raisins, is frosted with a classic Smith Island buttercream frosting, and hand patted with a layer of Toasted Black Walnuts. Approximately 9" in diameter and 3.5" tall, and yields 14-16…
Premium Shipping Included
Cookies and Cream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
New! Our Cookies and Cream Smith Island Cake is a made from scratch, moist Chocolate Cake, with Vanilla Buttercream and Oreo Cookie Frosting. All topped with crushed Oreo Cookies! Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Granulated Sugar, All Purpose Flour, Unsalted Butter, Oreo Cookies, Evaporated Milk, Whole…
Premium Shipping Included
Double Chocolate Raspberry Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Our Double Chocolate and Raspberry Smith Island Cake is made from scratch, and is a wonderful combination of moist Chocolate Cake, Housemade Fudge Frosting, and Raspberry Filling. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: All Purpose Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Unsalted Butter, Granulated Sugar, Seedless Raspberry Filling, Evaporated Milk, Whole Eggs, High…
Premium Shipping Included
Lemon Cream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Originally developed exclusively for Nordstrom Cafe, this cake features moist, made from scratch Lemon Cake, Housemade Lemon Curd, and Lemon Buttercream Frosting. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Confectioner's Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Lemon Juice, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Lemon Extract, Salt, Baking Powder, Baking…
Premium Shipping Included
Old Bay Buttercream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
NEW, our boldest flavor yet! If you love Old Bay (or even if you don't) you will LOVE this cake. Sweet, creamy, a little spicy, a little salty, and unmistakably delicious. Made from scratch moist Vanilla Cake, and an Old Bay Buttercream Frosting. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Confectioner’s…
Premium Shipping Included
Original Chocolate Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Enjoy the Cake that Launched a Thousand Ships! Our most popular offering, and Maryland's State Dessert. Made from scratch layers of moist Yellow Cake and Homemade Fudge Frosting. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Soybean Oil, Evaporated Milk, High Fat…
Premium Shipping Included
Red White and Blue Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Celebrate America with our Red White and Blue Smith Island Cake! Alternating layers of made from scratch Blueberry and Red Velvet Cake, our Housemade Buttercream Frosting, and sprinkled with Red and Blue "Firework" Crumbs. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter,…
Premium Shipping Included
Strawberry Lemon Coconut Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Perfect for Spring, or any occasion, features moist Vanilla Cake, alternating layers of Strawberry and Lemon Curd, wrapped in Housemade Vanilla buttercream, and hand patted with Toasted Coconut. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Unsalted Butter, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Confectioner's Sugar, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Strawberry Filling,…
Premium Shipping Included
Vanilla Buttercream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
New! Simple, classic, and delicious. Our wildly popular, made-from-scratch moist Vanilla Cake, and our fabulous Buttercream Frosting. The cake is approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Baking Soda, Baking Powder
Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs,…
Premium Shipping Included
Banana Cream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Layers of moist, made from scratch Banana Cake, and covered in our Housemade Vanilla Buttercream Frosting. The cake is approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs. and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Banana, All Purpose Flour, Granulated Sugar, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Soybean Oil, Whole Eggs, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Pure Vanilla Extract, Salt
Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy,…
Premium Shipping Included
Caramel Cream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
The most elegant Caramel Cake on the Planet, previously featured in Neiman Marcus Holiday Catalog! Moist Yellow Cake, Housemade Caramel, and a light, fluffy Caramel-Infused Buttercream. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Cake Flour, Heavy Cream, Whole Eggs, Butter, Light Corn Syrup, Vegetable Oil, Brown Sugar, Water, Corn…
Premium Shipping Included
Carrot Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Made from scratch with real carrots, comprising layers of moist Carrot Cake and Housemade Vanilla Buttercream Frosting. Approximately 9" in diameter and 3.5" tall, and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Carrot, Whole Eggs, Canola Oil, Confectioner’s Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Pineapple, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Pure Vanilla Extract, Nutmeg, Salt, Cinnamon
Allergens: Contains Wheat, Soy, Eggs, Milk,…
Premium Shipping Included
Chocolate Buttercream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
New! Our Chocolate Buttercream Smith Island Cake is made from scratch, featuring layers of moist Chocolate Cake, and our fabulous Buttercream Frosting. The cake is approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Granulated Sugar, All Purpose Flour, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Whole Eggs, High Fat Cocoa, Canola Oil,…
Premium Shipping Included
Chocolate Peanut Butter Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Our wildly popular, made-from-scratch Chocolate and Peanut Butter Smith Island Cake features layers of moist Yellow Cake, and alternating layers of Fudge Frosting and Housemade Peanut Butter Mousse. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Peanut Butter, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Soybean Oil, Evaporated Milk, High…
Premium Shipping Included
Cooked Coconut Smith Island Cake (Larger)
The most wonderful Coconut Cake in the world, once featured on the cover of the Neiman Marcus Holiday Catalog! Layers of moist Yellow Cake, an amazing Cooked Coconut Icing, and hand-patted with Coconut Shavings. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Whole Eggs, Coconut, Unsalted Butter, Soybean…
Premium Shipping Included
Double Chocolate Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Our Double Chocolate Smith Island Cake is a chocolate lover's dream. Made from scratch, it features layers of moist Chocolate Cake, and our Homemade Fudge Frosting. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: All Purpose Flour, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Milk, Granulated Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Evaporated Milk, Whole Eggs, High Fat Cocoa, Canola Oil, Pure…
Premium Shipping Included
Red Velvet Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Our Red Velvet Smith Island Cake is in a league of its own! Moist, made from scratch Red Velvet Cake and our Housemade Buttercream Frosting. The cake is approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour, Granulated Sugar, Whole Milk, Confectioner’s Sugar, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter, Canola Oil, Evaporated Milk, Red Food…
Premium Shipping Included
Strawberry Cream Smith Island Cake (Larger)
Considering Marion Station, Maryland, just up the road from Crisfield, is known as "The Strawberry Capital of the World", it's only fitting we feature a cake worthy of such a legacy! Featuring moist, made from scratch Yellow Cake, Housemade Buttercream Frosting and Strawberry Filling. Approximately 9" in diameter, 3.5" tall, weighs 5 lbs., and yields 14-16 slices.
Ingredients: Cake Flour,…
Premium Shipping Included
Result Pages: